why was peter pettigrew in gryffindor

Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. My sense is that Godric Gryffindor's definitions of "daring" and "nerve" did not include a person joining a group like the Death Eaters. Samoa Mexico So he was missing one of the most important Slytherin traits. United Kingdom Doesn't mean he couldn't sometimes outwit someone (look what he did to Sirius) but still that has nothing to do with courage. Puerto Rico All it has is Legilimency. Democratic Republic of the Congo British Virgin Islands Tajikistan I imagine because he was terrified of being put in Slytherin and tried to persuade the sorting hat! Shruthi Peter Pettigrew is a snivelling, cowardly, stupid, idiotic, mean, rat. etunusexquattuor " home message Hogwarts track. You know, I sometimes think we Sort too soon. Faroe Islands Peter Pettigrew got into Gryffindor, even though he was a coward, because he valued the traits of courage and chivalry. Spain Indonesia New Zealand He was out to make - seemingly, largely destructive and malicious - mischief, and aimed for power. Nigeria Is there a Flaw with Gryffindor's "Characteristics"? Romania Some of them are kind, some are ambitious, some are . McGonagall and Peter Pettigrew. He faced his boggarts . Somalia Lets talk about Peter Pettigrew should he have been a Slytherin? Relive all the magic of Newt's world with this hardback guidebook featuring all you need to know about Newt from the movie. Armenia The way I think of the hat is this. Bangladesh Keep reading He actually doesn't seem ambitious at all to me. Found insideA feat of imagination and featuring a cast of remarkable characters and magical creatures, this is epic adventure-packed storytelling at its very best. U.S. Virgin Islands GRRRRYFFINDOR" Not one person in the Great Hall cheered louder than Evelyn Hardcastle, who was standing on her chair, clapping and hollering. He is neither smart, nor sly. And then a war with Voldemort started, which could have pushed his fear to new levels. 1.5M ratings 277k ratings See, that's what the app is perfect for. If he became a Death Eater, why wasnt he sorted into Slytherin?" "Well, Harry one thing you need to understand is that not all Slytherins are evil." Remus said. They want to have high morals and don't want to let the people they care about down. While the implication is that he should be in Slytherin, he probably . Niger Slovakia Costa Rica Republic of the Congo Why was Peter Pettigrew in Gryffindor? Lacking all his growth in the early parts of 7, Harry could not have given up the Elder Wand's power. ”. But just because he’s a Death Eater doesn’t mean he’s a good Slytherin. El Salvador Because he is brave, he even stands up to his friends. And yet Peter must have spoken that day to the hat and asked for strength, he must have said something about courage or had a burning desire for bravery. How is Peter brave? Gryffindor Alone. Republic of the Congo Close. Namibia After all, for all we know, he could have anaesthetized himself quite thoroughly beforehand. Found inside – Page 195... and Seeker for the Gryffindor Quidditch team – can speak Parseltongue (snake ... and Peter Pettigrew POTTER, Lily – Harry's mother and Petunia Dursley's ... Now Peter on the other hand, he was desperate for people to like him, he could somehow talk all four of them out of trouble and have the teacher laughing away at the same time, one second their hands were covered in the red dye they had used to turn the green in the Slytherin Quittich robes into a Gryffindor red and the next second the teacher was walking away laughing about "Dumbledore and . "GRYFFINDOR" "Peter Pettigrew!" "GRYFFINDOR" "James Potter!" Evelyn, Sirius, Peter and Remus were all whispering the same thing; one single word, hoping it would be the one the Sorting Hat would call out next. Myanmar Thailand United States Found insidepher's Stone begins, fans imagine the sorting hat granting Peter Pettigrew's request to be sorted into Gryffindor house, despite finding it a bad fit (hPhc ... Turkmenistan Liberia Eritrea Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange! To put it another way, until graduation from Hogwarts, James Potter displayed more Slytherin-like qualities than Wormtail did. Vietnam To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. Harry Potter was strongly considered for Slytherin, because he DID, at the time, want power. [5], Peter's cowardly nature ensured that he was never suspected of being a spy, even when the Order gained awareness that they had a spy in their ranks. But should he be put into Gryffindor? Kyrgyzstan It could have been that Tom Riddle choose Peter. While many of the good things about . Tuvalu Peru On one hand, Slytherin is a perfect fit, especially taking Phineas Nigellus’s thoughts on the matter into account. Friends with Sirius, James and Remus. Jamaica Why do edo (eat) and edo (generate) have different forms? Liechtenstein The beauty of the house system is . Kosovo First of all, remember that sorting isn't about the qualities you have, it's about what you value. “Hey! Denmark Bouvet Island His best friends of James Potter, Remus Lupin and Peter Pettigrew accept him as the man he has become; strong, loyal and an . Svalbard and Jan Mayen Luxembourg For this is a town where food is scarce and rats are hated, where cellars are lined with deadly traps, and where a terrifying evil lurks beneath the hunger-stricken streets. Tunisia Latvia He escaped from Azkaban to find Pettigrew and . When Pettigrew was caring about the helpless and bodyless Voldemort, and later when he served the risen Voldemort, he might seem like playing coward if you only look at how he was sucking up to the Dark Lord, but he did actually need considerable bravery at those times. The inherent foolishness of their wandering Hogsmead with a full-blown werewolf does not take away from their basic good intentions. But consider how Peter has become a Death eater. Yemen He stuck to those he perceived as strong, if Sirius saw him correctly, but being a hanger on isn't really much of a goal. Micronesia Why was Neville Longbottom in Gryffindor? But Snape was put > right where he belonged. Mauritania Not to mention Pettigrew was definitely clever, resourceful, and cunning – three salient Slytherin traits. Saint Martin Bonaire, Saint Eustatius and Saba For instance, given the choice, we [Slytherins] will always choose to save our own necks.” – Phineas Nigellus. When Pettigrew was Sorted, he was balanced on the edge between Gryffindor and Slytherin. Cambodia Mayotte “Karkaroff intends to flee if the Mark burns.”, “Does he?” said Dumbledore softly, as Fleur Delacour and Roger Davies Cuba How to put multiple -I, -L and -l flags in ./configure? Pettigrew possessed and lacked qualities of both Slytherin and . That would be true if you were talking about a Death Eater who just mindlessly runs errands for Lord Voldemort, tortures Muggles, and enjoys the bullying. San Marino Kenya Qatar Suriname Share. Liberia While his very being does contradict all of the characteristics of the Gryffindor house, he is not any more suited for any other house. It can only determine someone's disposition from what is in their head at that time: their thoughts, their memories. He began attending Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry in 1971 and was sorted into Gryffindor House after the Sorting Hat pondered over which house he belonged in for over . Perhaps he had enough bravery, or potential for bravery, to develop into a true Gryffindor, much as Neville Longbottom did. Montenegro Palau Peter Pettigrew knows his three friends too well, they don't fully believe him, but the pride and blind arrogance have blinded their eyes, even if they don't trust him, but in the face of Dumbledore's inquiry, they will still support him. But what mattered was that she herself valued bravery over intelligence (she explicitly says this at the end of PS). Poland Listen, I don't have the slightest clue why The Dark lord chose me instead of you. Samoa But in Harry's case it is shown that the hat takes the student's preferences in to consideration. Despite being classified as Gryffindor, he lacked true bravery, perhaps proving that the Sorting Hat saw potential in him rather than any real innate courage, a potential which he never achieved. Initially, she didn't display much of this, but she had grown into it by the end of the first book. Ecuador Zambia Peter is the ultimate follower, he moves to what he perceives as the strongest single voice in the room. But no surprise: this was decades after the Sorting Hat, just barely, though that he had an aptitude for Gryffindor. / more — . While as an adult, Peter was a sniveling coward, he was not that way as a kid. He seeks protection in others. Equatorial Guinea Comoros Japan 5 October. Andorra Posted by 4 years ago. To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. Why? Chapter 41: The Room 7.4K 289 45. by sarazik. MuggleNet is an unofficial Harry Potter fansite.Please email us if you have any questions or concerns.© 1999–2021 MuggleNet.com. Quite a lot more than 'a bit'. Svalbard and Jan Mayen "There wouldn't be any Muggle girls left! Crimson and gold Brown and gold. > > IMO, the best explanation comes down to the fact that the Hat selects what qualities you value most, not what you actually are. Because of his cowardice, Peter was also an opportunist, looking always at people stronger and braver than him. Saudi Arabia Of course, there's also the possibility that it has quotas :-) Perhaps in Pettigrew's year they were a bit light on the Gryffindors. Carefully curated by the British Library and full of extraordinary treasures from all over the world, this is an unforgettable journey exploring the history of the magic at the heart of the Harry Potter stories. Tonga Singapore Monaco Latvia Their daring, nerve, and chivalry Politics can make spectacular bedfellows. But did he let him live out of bravery though? Estonia South Sudan Croatia Guinea Burkina Faso The Sorting Hat, Why are there three pins in this relay diagram? Number one we know Snape is brave, even as a young child he is cited standing up for his mother when his father is abusive. manner in which Pettigrew died as (dubious) evidence. American Samoa Sometimes uses "they" pronouns but isn't comfortable discussing it much yet. @Slytherincess: At eleven, Harry Potter had spent his entire life being dumped upon and overshadowed. He and Sirius were awful to Severus and iirc they also hexed other people too just because they thought it was funny. Contrary to those who reject the Harry Potter books as a threat to Christian faith, Neal demonstrates how the lessons in these books reinforce the central messages of the Bible. France Why Peter Pettigrew was a Gryffindor. Poland notjustaprettyface-youknow:. Had things in their lives NOT gone as they did, they may have turned out very differently. v2 Harry Potter Archives His true nature, however, tempered that greatly and helped him become the man he was at the end of book 7. . A/N—Lately I have been thinking about why Peter betrayed James. Laos Madagascar Djibouti Its not a clever or ambitious thing to do. But what happened after his Sorting? It only takes a minute to sign up. Neville gradually developed his courage. Albania Guatemala Greenland Ethiopia Bolivia Puerto Rico As for hiding out rather than seeking the Dark Lord? El Salvador In chapter 33 of the Goblet of Fire, Voldemort himself praises Peter for seeking Voldemort while he was powerless, caring for him, and helping him return. therepeterbecheese-blog . Mozambique Thus, many people argue that Pettigrew would fit better into Slytherin. 11 comments. He always sought protection. United States Minor Outlying Islands Peter Pettigrew. The powerful Dark wizard Gellert Grindelwald was captured in New York with the help of Newt Scamander. It's a possibility. Belgium retribution; you know how much help he gave the Ministry after the Why was Peter Pettigrew in Gryffindor? Australia Found insideWho will triumph in an election fraught with passion, duplicity, and unexpected revelations? A big novel about a small town, The Casual Vacancy is J.K. Rowling's first novel for adults. It is the work of a storyteller like no other. April 28, 2005 – It is announced that the Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince audio edition is to be released on August 25, 2005 in the United Kingdom. We see a follower, someone who’s impressed by his companions and longs to be like them but can’t quite measure up. Why wasnt Peter Pettigrew in Slytherin? It would certainly be important, though. New Caledonia —- Why do I feel like you're talking about a certain someone? Israel Uzbekistan Anguilla im-sirius-dude. Imagine if you will a young Snape. #black #drama #era #fan #fanfiction #fiction #harry #hogwarts #james #lupin #marauder #marauders #peter #pettigrew #potter #remus #romance #sapphire #sirius. Archived. Portugal Maybe Wormtail isn't that just strong with his own feet, maybe there are some points that Wormtail is a coward, but like everyone who was sorted to different houses, the Sorting hat bases the qualification based on their own attitude. Think about the image we get of Pettigrew before his betrayal. Grenada Later in life, he made the conscious choice to set aside power - he'd grown and changed as a person. Iceland Kazakhstan French Guiana He has accepted to become the secret-keeper for Lily and James' hiding place, then went straight to Lord Voldemort to betray them. Dumbledore's answer to Harry about the houses probably is the closest we . At the same time, Pettigrew was never particularly “ambitious” or “power-hungry” – preferring to “out of cowardice, stand in the shadow of the strongest person,” according to J.K. Rowling. @Jeff - I really like your answer a lot! Chad Vatican The American edition is set to be released in the United States and Canada on July 16, 2005. Oman Jamaica All right, so we’ve established that despite the instinctive urge to put all the villains in one House, Peter Pettigrew is not a Slytherin. His first magical act was punishment of his cousin (coupled with freeing a prisoner). China Sirius and Remus become the inseparable friends of James Potter and Peter Pettigrew. Burundi Funnily enough, Harry Potter himself provides us with an answer. Bosnia and Herzegovina As he was a Gryffindor, the fact that he was such a huge coward doesn't make a lot of sense. Niue All rights reserved. East Timor Vietnam The light reveals invisible ink secrets on the fold-out map pages, while the pen can help readers create their own magical map, using the blank parchment included at the back of this book. Full color. Consumable. Plus, it helped that one could (in actuality), choose. Why did Peter Pettigrew have the Dark Mark? At the end of the day . 75% Upvoted . Each of these characters was Sorted based on what they had the potential for, not what they were. Privacy Policy | COPPA Policy | Terms of Use | FeedbackMuggleNet is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program and Bookshop.org's affiliate program, affiliate advertising programs designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com and bookshop.org. Peter Pettigrew Gryffindor | 6th Year | Halfblood Posts; Likes; Following; Ask me anything; Submit a post; Archive; wordsofpoison-deactivated201806. Malta “I don’t go looking for trouble. Libya " She'd kept on reading quietly, and Harry Potter had kept on trying to apologize, and it had soon dawned on Hermione that Harry had realized, possibly for the first time in his life, that he'd done something annoying; and that Harry, definitely for the first . Peter Pettigrew, O.M. A choice assumes he felt he actually had a choice. This is important. M e m b e r c o u n t : 1 admin; 8 members G e n r e : Marauders Era Roleplay (Harry Potter) A d m i n s : On mobile from 6:00am-4:00pm every weekday, but constantly checking! Without his experiences in DA and the encouragement he got at the end of the very first book, Neville would never have had the courage he displayed in Book 7. mary-andthesaints:. Nepal In this video, we're going to be discussing the widely-hated Peter Pettigrew. I don't recall vaguely waving my hand in front of @Slytherincess muttering "those aren't the answers you are looking for". @Xantec - The Sorting Hat's very magical, but not infallible, IMO. He’s far from cunning and never seems to display any ambition, especially given that he was okay living as a rat for 12 years. Swaziland Gambia Uganda How do I read papers relevant to my research that are written in a language I do not know? I had always thought of Peter Pettigrew as wimpy and cowardly, … More. Malta He chose not to kill Harry Potter in Malfoy dungeon (for which his silver hand killed him). What happens behind the scenes when a EU covid vaccine certificate gets scanned? Why would he immediately not have been sorted into Slytherin? But I didn't do anything to "steal" it! Sri Lanka But after that, I think finding and resurrect the Dark Lord is brave, when Peter could have instead just continued to hide from the world without seeking the Dark Lord, or sought out the Dark Lord but betrayed him while he was weak. South Sudan Found inside – Page 86While Peter Pettigrew belonged to Gryffindor, he is weak and disloyal; Hermione reveals that the Hat had debated about putting her in Ravenclaw before ... Turkmenistan I was reading up on house traits while listening to the books and it really doesn't make sense. Peter Pettigrew is probably one of the more despised Harry Potter characters out there. Northern Mariana Islands His greatest weakness is his greatest ambition. Jersey Sirius Black, son of the socialite and wealthy Voldemort supporting Orion and Walburga Black, is the renegade of his family; refusing to accept his blood, he seeks solace in open and welcoming arms of Gryffindor House. Slovakia I will explain. I have all the information," Pettigrew replied. Sudan Why was he sorted into Gryffindor? Bahrain Algeria China In the books, James, Peter, Remus and Sirius are portrayed as huge assholes—Sirius plays a prank on Severus . As for the Hat It never admits its wrong so as far as it is concerned it did foresee everything perfectly. It . He LAUGHS in the face of danger! Kiribati @Jeff his first magical act wasn't freeing the snake; it's mentioned that he also made his hair grow back after his Aunt had cut it horribly, shrunk an awful sweater she was forcing him to wear, and flew to the top of the school when being chased by bullies, all prior to that incident. Neville Longbottom and Peter Pettigrew: An Experiment in Sorting Pagina Catalogata come Supposizioni, teorie, approfondimenti I have long been troubled by the fact that Peter Pettigrew was sorted into Gryffindor; of course, for reasons of plot it makes sense, since he needed to be close friends with the rest of the Marauders and Hogwarts tends to be cliquey with their Houses. It’s hard to see that sometimes, given what he becomes, but there are moments of bravery that shine through. Vatican Solomon Islands Isle of Man Have you forgotten? @Pryftan You're mixing two or three different times in Peter's life here. He may have been on the wrong side, but he still fought. hide. 2. Bahamas It’s possible to influence the Sorting Hat with your own wishes and desires. British Indian Ocean Territory Netherlands Saint Kitts and Nevis Soon the rest of the . However, Slytherin also values ambition and resourcefulness, both of which Harry has displayed many times (ambition to be an Auror, to defeat Voldemort, etc). Which leads me to ask: did the Sorting Hat know Harry was a. Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. Sirius accuses him of this in the Prisoner of Azkaban, and while Peter later denies this and claims he's done it only because the Dark Lord has forced him, Sirius's arguments are convincing: Peter has betrayed the Marauders on his own accord, using a clever plan. I would postulate that Pettigrew became a Gryffindor in the same way that Harry did: In the end, after five and a half long minutes, he asked for it. Remember, Peter's mother is still alive, and it's implied she's his only family (she is awarded Peter's "posthumous" Order of Merlin). Western Sahara The Riddles of Harry Potter draws readers into the deeper meanings of these phenomenally successful books, arguing that they launch and pursue interpretive quests in an ongoing effort to understand patterns and their attendant meanings, ... Rwanda Lebanon That is because Peter Pettigrew is a Gryffindor. Gryffindor. First, there’s his decision to become an illegal Animagus, a process full of risk, and then choose to spend full moons with a werewolf, a dangerous undertaking, especially given that Peter was a small prey animal. Kuwait Brunei Which will he draw strength from? But the point is, Wormtail is somehow brave. It is a pity that Peter was so afraid, for he did not realize like our own hero did that there is nothing to fear but fear itself. “And are you tempted to join him?”, “No,” said Snape, his black eyes on Fleur’s and Roger’s retreating Iraq Coworkers treating me differently for being the only one not doing free overtime. Copy. Egypt Here's my idea. 1 2 » Cheating just proves how unintelligent people are. Nepal I'm also fairly certain Peter was tortured. Obviously he grew up to be a coward anyways but the hat often seems to weigh these options between what the characters value, what the possess, and what they will grow to be (eg Neville). Liechtenstein It was because of him that James and Lily Potter died. Because whatever desire he has to do good comes second place to his own well-being. Panama Secondly, consider the role Peter has played in the Dark Lord rising again. Cameroon Greece Mali “You are a braver man by far than Igor Libya you can't use dog as an insult as i am a dog and dogs . Pureblood. Examines the meanings behind the names of people and places in the Harry Potter books. Namibia I think it's mostly spot on, although, as I mentioned previously, I don't think potential is the only consideration. What is the earliest reference in fiction to a government-approved thieves guild? Gambia If you take an 11-year-old boy, who’s done nothing wrong, who desperately wants to be a hero, and put him under the Sorting Hat, what happens? Yemen And that is fairly deserved. In the end, the Sorting Hat simply could not have foreseen all this. Paraguay Are there any canon examples of Peter Pettigrew displaying any of the aforementioned traits in a positive way? Togo Sweden Slovenia Tanzania The circumstances of Peters death are not dismissable. Cayman Islands You argue that joining the Death Eaters doesn't count as daring. I think we’ve all asked ourselves this question at some point: Why was Peter Pettigrew in Gryffindor House? He is BRAVE! (First Class), (c. 1959 / 1960 - March, 1998 ), usually referred to as Wormtail or Scabbers was a wizard and the son of Mr and Mrs Pettigrew. "Why," Harry paused, "Why was Peter Pettigrew sorted into Gryffindor? Are there any canon examples of Peter Pettigrew displaying any of the aforementioned traits in a positive way? Georgia Maldives If you didn't know anything post-Hogwarts-years, I don't think most of the things that we are shown James Potter engaging in would be "Godric Gryffindor's definitions" either. Instead of spending three nights in utter misery each month, his friends' courage (and adolescent belief in their own infallibity and immortality) gave him a sense of belonging and camaraderie, an important part of growing up in any society. Serbia If we consider all the houses it makes sense that the place Peter would thrive most in a place where bravery and chivalry existed. But someone who is hurting, who needs strength in themselves - should they be put into a roomful of arrogant and brave Gryffindors? Belarus Zimbabwe, “Harry Potter and the Art of Spying” Authors to Attend Chestertown “Potter” Festival. Botswana It . Unlike the hand, which I will get to later. Was it required at Hogwarts that a Head of House have been a student in that House? French Polynesia Moldova But that doesn't impress me all that much, honestly. When: Afternoon Notes: it's great, thank you for starting! Panama Syria Colombia Russia Why Did Peter Pettigrew Become a Death Eater? By . Russia > Why Peter Pettigrew was sorted to Gryfindor has always been a mystery > to me, and now it looks like it always will be. Why was Peter Pettigrew in Gryffindor? Iceland Sudan Austria Mauritius Saint Helena Cameroon Afghanistan Laos Alas our poor friend Peter was afraid. There was a moment, however small, where he considered defying Voldemort’s orders in order to do the honorable thing, which would be repaying the debt. One might also reference the fact that the Sorting Hat takes the individuals wants into consideration, as seen in Chamber of Secrets when Harry questions why he was put into Gryffindor, and at the end of The Deathly Hallows, when Harry tells his son that the Sorting Hat takes his choice into consideration. Azerbaijan My sense is that Godric Gryffindor's definitions of "daring" and "nerve" did not include a person joining a group like the Death Eaters. Eritrea You know Sirius was not a coward. Okay sure it must have been scary but that's just a moment in time but having moments of bravery isn't the same thing as being brave in general. Israel As long as he is still a member of this small group, the three of them will support themselves unconditionally. Mali Cape Verde Guyana And it was.". Oman It's also arguable that he fully anticipated Voldemort to replace his hand (for all we know he was told directly that he would). Trinidad and Tobago Peter Pettigrew. Serbia Share. He wanted to be a hero but was always outshone by his more impressive friends. Karkaroff. Kuwait Scared and tortured by his Father. So perhaps Peter wanted to join Gryffindor strongly enough that that is where it put him? Paraguay Saint Pierre and Miquelon Despite the Sorting Hat's stubborn insistence otherwise, it is quite possible for people to change between their Sorting and their death, a fact that Dumbledore recognized: “Karkaroff’s Mark is becoming darker too. Sao Tome and Principe "All the ones i know are," Harry said, "Who told you that?" Remus smiled, remembering something. The hat puts one where one chooses to be and or- where a person will thrive. Updated October 1, 2020. Uruguay A bit of a bully? Dominican Republic India Montserrat He was a . For a lot of reasons, Peter Pettigrew, AKA "Wormtail", may be one of the creepiest characters in all of the Harry Potter series. Guinea-Bissau . This compendium showcases EVERY character ever mentioned in the Harry Potter books, films and play: the good, the bad and the misunderstood. With more than 700 entries, this book is packed from cover to cover! Who: Mary MacDonald and Peter Pettigrew Where: Outside near the lake. Spain Bahamas Afghanistan Brunei Jordan Equatorial Guinea Vanuatu Found inside – Page 277Gryffindor Peter Pettigrew demonstrated the other vice associated with courage, its deficiency of cowardice, when he betrayed Harry's parents to Voldemort.
Worm Lesson Plans For Kindergarten, When Was Hippocrates Born, Cheri Animal Crossing Ranking, Steam Inhalation With Oregano Leaves, Delinquent Harry Potter Fanfiction, Fbi Agent Names Generator, Miracle Bamboo Pillow Washing Instructions, Appzapper 2 Registration Code, University Of Michigan Biostatistics Phd, Harry Stops Talking Fanfiction, List Of Street In Minnesota, Wholesale Unstuffed Plush Animal Skins, Best Men's Haircut Portsmouth, Nh, Usmc Dress Blue Deltas, Friendship Abbreviations List,